Plainclothes (2025)
12-month trend
12-month trend
Monthly article views
2025-09 to 2026-08
A plainclothes officer in 1990s New York struggles with his identity while conducting undercover operations against men in shopping malls.
The story
In 1990s upstate New York, Lucas Brennan is a plainclothes police officer assigned to an undercover sting operation targeting gay and bisexual men in shopping malls. He poses as a man seeking an encounter to lure men into restrooms for arrest. While the work is routine, it deeply troubles Lucas as he grapples with his own attraction to men and the recent death of his father. His personal life is strained by complicated family relationships. During one operation, Lucas becomes involved with Andrew Waters, a man he is meant to arrest, leading to a secret and complicated relationship that complicates his professional and personal life.
Full plot (contains spoilers)
In 1990s upstate New York, Lucas Brennan, a plainclothes police officer, conducts undercover sting operations targeting gay and bisexual men in shopping malls. While the work is routine, it troubles Lucas, who is struggling with his own attraction to men and the recent death of his father. During an operation, he meets Andrew Waters, a married pastor. Lucas uses the name 'Gus' to initiate a secret affair with Andrew. When Andrew learns Lucas is a police officer, he cuts off contact. Lucas later tracks Andrew down to his church and confronts him, outting him in front of his family. Following this, Lucas becomes isolated and writes unsent letters to Andrew. At a New Year's party, Lucas's mother and uncle find a letter from Andrew. A misunderstanding about the letter's intended recipient leads to a heated argument between Lucas and his uncle, Paul. The confrontation turns physical, and Lucas shoves Paul out a window in front of the guests. In the aftermath, Lucas tearfully reveals the truth of the letter to his mother, finally coming out to her.
- First release year
- 2025
- Runtime (minutes)
- 96
- Production countries
- United States; United Kingdom
- Original languages
- English
- Directors
- Carmen Emmi
- Writers
- Carmen Emmi · writer
- Cast and characters
- Tom Blyth · Lucas Brennan; Russell Tovey · Andrew Waters; Maria Dizzia · Marie Brennan; Christian Cooke · Ron; Gabe Fazio · Uncle Paul; Amy Forsyth · Emily; John Bedford Lloyd · Lt. Sollars; Darius Fraser · Jeff; Alessandra Ford Balazs · Jessie; Sam Asa Brownstein · Christian
- Genres
- romantic thriller; drama
- Themes
- Identity; Closeted life; Duty vs. Desire
- Tone and mood
- Dramatic; Tense
- Setting
- Upstate New York in the 1990s
- Premise and plot tags
- Undercover; Police Procedural; LGBTQ+
- Reception
- The film received generally favorable reviews from critics.
- Reported review scores
- Metacritic · score: 65 · scale: 100 · review count: 13
- Awards and nominations
- Special Jury Award for Ensemble Cast · Sundance Film Festival · Won
- Production trivia
- The film marks the feature length directorial debut for Carmen Emmi.; Filming began in Syracuse, New York in March 2024.
Film metadata comes from the open sources listed in Credits & Contact. Catalogue details may be incomplete.
Your lists
Loading your lists…